Both Bills have been passed by Parliament and transmitted to the President. Assessing them against constitutional reservations he first raised in 2020, when he referred the Bills back to Parliament under section 79 of the Constitution, the President concluded that some of those reservations remain unaddressed and referred the contested provisions to the Constitutional Court. The judgment of the Constitutional Court is awaited before the fate of the Bills can be determined.
Mapping stakeholder submissions to Parliament
Between 2017 and 2023, across two cycles of public hearings (the 2017–2018 National Assembly hearings and the 2021–2023 re-hearings and National Council of Provinces hearings), South Africa’s Parliament received 176 written submissions and oral presentations on the reforms. The submissions and presentations came from academics, creator and performer associations, collective management organisations, publishers and broadcasters, streaming and technology firms, libraries and archives, disability-rights groups, trade unions, government entities and civil-society organisations, alongside a number of international voices.
Participatory democracy – whether in the form of citizens participating in democratic processes of reform or in the form of citizens creating and reusing copyright-protected materials in the exercise of their rights to freedom of expression and cultural participation – can shape copyright reform. How that happened in South Africa’s case is worth exploring as an illustration from the Global South. In South Africa, open parliamentary consultation produced a broadly public-interest consensus that prioritised user exceptions and educational access. The for-profit and industry bloc, which was unable to secure consensus on the core contested clauses, re-litigated its position through the executive, informing the President’s constitutional reservations and the eventual referral to the Constitutional Court.
To examine the role of participatory democracy in this process, we coded every submission to Parliament, capturing each stakeholder’s overall stance on the Copyright Amendment Bill, the specific clauses they engaged with, the legal justifications they offered, and the constitutional provisions they invoked. The table below presents a first, summary view of the results: it maps the twenty stakeholder groups that registered a position on the CAB against their overall stance and the constitutional grounds they advanced.
The question that informed this mapping was: How does participatory democracy shape copyright reform in the Global South, and what lessons can be learned for future copyright reform and copyright litigation, particularly regarding the use of legislative history in statutory interpretation?
The table below presents the initial results of our mapping. Each row represents a stakeholder group. The stance column shows the group’s dominant (most common) position on the Bill, with the full spread of positions and the number of submissions in each category reported beneath it. The constitutional-basis column lists the provisions of the Bill of Rights the group most frequently cited, with the number of submissions citing each. Positions are colour-coded from support (green) to opposition (red); “implied” denotes a constitutional argument made without naming a specific section, and “not stated” denotes a position taken without an express constitutional argument. Rows run from the most support-leaning groups to the most opposition-leaning.
SupportConditional supportOppose unless amendedOpposeNot stated / Unclear
Property (s 25)Freedom of trade (s 22)Equality (s 9)Education (s 29)Dignity (s 10)Freedom of expression (s 16)Implied (not specifically itemised)Not stated
| Stakeholder group | Subs. | Stance on the Copyright Amendment Bill | Constitutional basis for stance (top provisions cited) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Auction house / art marketⓘExample submitters
Aspire Art Auctions | Strauss & Co (auction house) For-profit / Industry
|
2 | Support
Support 1 · Conditional support 1
|
Implied (not specifically itemised) 1Not stated 1
|
|
Disability rightsⓘExample submitters
Blind SA & Section 27 (Jace Nair, CEO Blind SA) | Blind SA — 2017 Presentation | Blind SA — 2017 Submission | Blind SA — Written Submission (Jace Nair) | SANCB Copyright Alliance (SANCB, Tape Aids for the Blind, SA Non-profit / Public-interest
|
6 | Support
Support 4 · Conditional support 2
|
Equality (s 9) 6Education (s 29) 5Dignity (s 10) 3
|
|
Education unionⓘExample submitters
ReCreate (coalition incl. SADTU, SAGA) | SADTU Bohlabela Region | SADTU JB Marks Region | SADTU Northern Cape Region | SADTU Pixley ka Seme Region Non-profit / Public-interest
|
7 | Support
Support 7
|
Equality (s 9) 7Education (s 29) 6Dignity (s 10) 1
|
|
Libraries / archivesⓘExample submitters
LIASA — 2017 Submission | Library and Information Association of South Africa (LIASA — | Library and Information Association of South Africa (LIASA) | Library and Information Association of South Africa (LIASA) Non-profit / Public-interest
|
4 | Support
Support 4
|
Implied (not specifically itemised) 3Education (s 29) 1Equality (s 9) 1
|
|
Performer associationⓘExample submitters
FEDUSA, UASA and SAGA (joint trade-union and performer-assoc | South African Guild of Actors (SAGA) | South African Guild of Actors (SAGA) — 2017 | South African Guild of Actors (SAGA) — 2017 Presentation | South African Guild of Actors (SAGA) — Written Submission Non-profit / Public-interest
|
5 | Support
Support 4 · Conditional support 1
|
Freedom of trade (s 22) 4Dignity (s 10) 1Equality (s 9) 1
|
|
Performer-manager bodyⓘExample submitters
Personal Managers' Association (PMA) | Personal Managers' Association (PMA) — Written Submission Non-profit / Public-interest
|
2 | Support
Support 2
|
Freedom of trade (s 22) 2
|
|
Trade union federationⓘExample submitters
COSATU — 2021 Presentation | Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU) | Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU) — 2021 Non-profit / Public-interest
|
3 | Support
Support 2 · Conditional support 1
|
Implied (not specifically itemised) 3
|
|
Civil society / NGOⓘExample submitters
Artists Unite for Fair Copyright Campaign (linked with ReCre | Association for Progressive Communications (APC) | Centre for Health Innovation and the Public Interest | Creative Commons (Kure; Vézina; West) | Creative Commons South Africa Non-profit / Public-interest
|
22 | Support
Support 20 · Conditional support 1 · Oppose 1
|
Education (s 29) 7Equality (s 9) 5Implied (not specifically itemised) 5
|
|
Individual creatorⓘExample submitters
Creative Legal Clinic / Goodwill King Advertising (Thulani G | Florence Masebe (actress / performer) | Kristel Birkholtz (musician / composer / recording artist) | SA Composers (joint submission by veteran composers / produc | Sag Loyola (individual creator) Non-profit / Public-interest
|
6 | Conditional support
Support 2 · Conditional support 3 · Oppose unless amended 1
|
Freedom of trade (s 22) 2Not stated 2Dignity (s 10) 1
|
|
AcademicⓘExample submitters
Academic and Non-Fiction Authors Association of South Africa | Dick Kawooya, PhD (University of South Carolina) | Dr Jade Kouletakis | Dr L. Tong | Hon Justice Michael Kirby (former High Court of Australia, I Non-profit / Public-interest
|
28 | Support
Support 20 · Conditional support 3 · Oppose 5
|
Equality (s 9) 12Education (s 29) 11Implied (not specifically itemised) 6
|
|
Government entityⓘExample submitters
Department of Science and Technology (DST) | Department of Science and Technology (DST) — Submission | National Council for Library and Information Services (NCLIS | National Film and Video Foundation (NFVF) | Western Cape Government — Department of Economic Development Non-profit / Public-interest
|
5 | Conditional support
Support 1 · Conditional support 3 · Oppose unless amended 1
|
Not stated 2Education (s 29) 1Equality (s 9) 1
|
|
Creator associationⓘExample submitters
Artists & Creatives for Fair Royalties and Fair Copyright | Australian Society of Authors / Australian copyright stakeho | Documentary Filmmakers Association (DFA) | Documentary Filmmakers Association (DFA) — Presentation | Electric South (immersive / VR media production) For-profit / Industry
|
15 | Oppose
Support 4 · Conditional support 2 · Oppose unless amended 1 · Oppose 8
|
Implied (not specifically itemised) 5Freedom of trade (s 22) 4Freedom of expression (s 16) 3
|
|
OtherⓘExample submitters
Aspire (creator-rights advocacy / industry presentation) | Association for Communication and Advertising (ACA) & Commer | LDC (Library Department / Legal Document Centre) | Licensing Executives Society SA (LES SA — Du Preez & Dohmen) | Marketing Association of South Africa (MASA) Other / Mixed
|
10 | Oppose
Support 1 · Conditional support 3 · Oppose unless amended 1 · Oppose 5
|
Freedom of trade (s 22) 3Implied (not specifically itemised) 3Property (s 25) 3
|
|
Streaming / TechⓘExample submitters
Amazon (Amazon Content Services LLC; Amazon.com Services LLC | Google South Africa (Pty) Ltd | Google South Africa (additional / annexure) | Netflix | Netflix — 2021 Written Submission For-profit / Industry
|
5 | Oppose unless amended
Support 2 · Oppose unless amended 3
|
Not stated 5
|
|
CMOⓘExample submitters
Composers, Authors and Publishers Association (CAPASSO) | Composers, Authors and Publishers Association (CAPASSO) — 20 | DALRO — 2017 Presentation | DALRO — 2017 Written Submission | Dramatic, Artistic & Literary Rights Organisation (DALRO) For-profit / Industry
|
18 | Oppose
Conditional support 1 · Oppose unless amended 3 · Oppose 14
|
Property (s 25) 15Freedom of trade (s 22) 4Not stated 2
|
|
IP-law professional societyⓘExample submitters
South African Institute of Intellectual Property Law (SAIIPL | Spoor & Fisher (IP law firm) Other / Mixed
|
6 | Oppose
Oppose 6
|
Property (s 25) 5Not stated 1
|
|
Industry coalitionⓘExample submitters
Copyright Alliance (predecessor to CCSA — industry coalition | Copyright Coalition of South Africa (CCSA) | Copyright Coalition of South Africa (CCSA) — Written Submiss | South African Federation Against Copyright Theft (SAFACT) / For-profit / Industry
|
4 | Oppose
Oppose 4
|
Property (s 25) 4
|
|
International business chamberⓘExample submitters
American Chamber of Commerce in South Africa (AMCHAM) For-profit / Industry
|
1 | Oppose
Oppose 1
|
Property (s 25) 1
|
|
Law firmⓘExample submitters
Baker & McKenzie (Janet MacKenzie & Fatima Ismail) For-profit / Industry
|
1 | Oppose
Oppose 1
|
Not stated 1
|
|
Publisher / broadcasterⓘExample submitters
GP Sports (sports broadcasting / rights body) | Independent Producers Organisation (IPO) & Animation SA (ASA | Independent Producers Organisation (IPO), Animation SA (ASA) | International Federation of Film Producers Associations (FIA | International Publishers Association (IPA — Geneva) For-profit / Industry
|
26 | Oppose
Oppose unless amended 11 · Oppose 15
|
Property (s 25) 15Implied (not specifically itemised) 10Freedom of expression (s 16) 4
|
Our mapping shows that public-interest actors (i.e., academics, civil-society organisations, libraries and archives, disability-rights groups, education unions, performers and trade unions) cluster on the side of support, and they tend to argue from equality (section 9), education (section 29) and dignity (section 10). For-profit and industry actors (i.e., publishers and broadcasters, collective management organisations, IP-law professional bodies and industry coalitions) cluster on the side of opposition, and they tend to argue from the right to property (section 25) and freedom of trade, occupation and profession (section 22). Property under section 25 is, in fact, the single most-invoked constitutional provision.
The table above provides an interim view of the data. We are developing the Copyright Debate Explorer, an interactive public dashboard that will enable users to explore positions on the Bills, trace constitutional arguments across stakeholder groups, and identify which submissions anticipated the constitutional reservations now before the Constitutional Court.
_________________________________________________________________________________________
Workshop
On 25–26 June 2026, Professor Chijioke Okorie’s paper drawn from this work — Copyright reform, participatory democracy and constitutional contestation in South Africa — will be presented at the 17th Annual Workshop of the International Society for the History and Theory of Intellectual Property (ISHTIP), hosted by the Faculty of Law of the University of São Paulo (USP), Brazil. This year’s workshop takes as its theme Intellectual Property and Democracy.
In keeping with ISHTIP’s distinctive format, the paper will be introduced not by its author but by a reader, with Carolina Botero, founder of the Karisma Foundation in Bogotá, serving as commentator. We look forward to a fruitful and stimulating discussion.
